Skip to main content

Cancel Mandatory State Testing in School Year 2020-2021

 Good morning -


I am an English Learner Program Coordinator in District 26 Cary. I have worked for over 15 years serving multilingual and multicultural communities in Lake, Cook, and McHenry counties. In alignment with administrators across the state, I want to advocate for the cancelling of ALL required state testing this year.


For students and families, this year has been challenging as we transition back-and-forth in between hybrid and remote instruction. Just now, based on current COVID-19 metrics, are we able to safely offer hybrid instruction. Hybrid instruction means that students will attend two days per week, two days with asynchronous activities, and one day of remote instruction. Families and communities have advocated strongly for in-person instruction to improve instruction, support the social-emotional development of students, and help students overcome the isolation of the last year.


Please cancel mandatory state testing this year. Planning in advance, administration of ACCESS and IAR will require six full days of assessment. There are currently 30 in-person days scheduled for hybrid instruction; thus, these assessments will consume 1/5 of the remaining in-person days, which will severely handicap schools' abilities to support  quality instruction, meaningful classroom assessment, and the social interaction that students direly need. Based on ISBE school designations, lower than 95% rate of completion of this assessment will have a detrimental impact on the summative designation of these schools. This lowering of summative designation will be due to nothing other than families and schools supporting a democratic approach to community health during a global pandemic.


Additionally, although families can opt-out of IAR instruction, our multilingual families do NOT have the option to opt out of ACCESS testing despite a significant percentage of multilingual families opting for fully remote instruction. Reviewing COVID-19 metrics, we know the disproportionate impact of medical/economic consequences for communities of color, multilingual communities. Therefore, while ISBE and your office support an equitable approach to supporting historically-marginalized communities, this additional testing will put the students at further health risk AND reduce the number of days that they can engage in meaningful instruction and peer interaction.


Additionally, COVID-19 hit us all by surprise: government, private sector, and schools. Even though schools rapidly innovated in collaboration with community and state/national guidance, we all know that remote instruction did not provide the same levels of engagement and academic learning that occur in the school setting. Who are the victims? Students, children. Why do we want to subject them to rigorous standardized assessments for which they are not prepared due to no fault of their own?


Families want their students in school for meaningful instruction and peer-to-peer interaction. None of these goals are supported by mandatory standardized testing. Instead, the inevitable outcome is 1/5 less days of quality instruction/interaction, penalization of schools, and the anxiety of academic underperformance in a year where children were the victims of unprecedented circumstances.


Please cancel all mandatory standardized testing this year.



Best regards,



Ryan Zak

ryan.zak@cary26.org

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Homework, Opportunity, and Equity

Rather than focusing this blog pot entirely on linguistic or cultural learning, I wanted to share a recent article about the role of homework in school and the mixed opinions about how effective it is. Although I fully anticipate a spectrum of opinions on homework, I think it's important to engage in ongoing dialogue and reflection on what homework we give, how much we give, how we assess it, and the different supports that different kids have to complete their homework. Below you can find the article broken apart into essential questions. In particular attention, what do we know absolutely about homework?  We know that homework is a disproportionate challenge for low-income students and incomplete homework impacts low-income students disproportionately .  While we must have high expectations for ALL students and hold ALL students accountable regardless of their life circumstances, educators should regularly reflect on their homework policy to assess the value of homewor...
Post a Comment
Read more

Supporting Latino Students to Maximize their Potential

In  "The Potential and Promise of Latino Students" (American Educator, Spring 2017) , Patricia Gándara describes the changing cultural and linguistic portrait of Latino students in the USA while reflecting on their potential and areas of struggle. In the section, "Why Latinos Fall Behind," Gándara reflects on a common trend in schools to identify second-language acquisition as the primary factor impacting Latino student's academic performance and growth. I wanted to deconstruct several of her quotations and analyze the potential impact our Latino students. Quotation:  "The simplistic and misguided explanation that language is the primary impediment to academic achievement overlooks the much more powerful role of poverty. Nearly two-third (62 percent) of Latino children live in or near poverty, and less than 20 percent of low-income Latinos live in households where anyone completed postsecondary education," (p.6).  Analysis:  Although many ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Tough Conversations: When Students Make Jokes about Race in the Classroom

Written by Rocío Robledo-Zak Interviewed by Ryan Zak During a session of guided reading, I was re-teaching a mini lesson on cause and effect with a group of students. The passage we were using involved an expository text on the Pony Express. After students read the passage to themselves, they had to identify and describe at least three causes and effects into their journals. Once they completed that task, we did a turn and share in the group. One student identified one cause by stating that the riders of the Pony Express crossed territorial lands to help deliver mail and the effect was that Indians would kill them for invading their lands. After I praised the student’s response, another student made a teasing comment towards that student, “you see what your people did to the riders.” The lighter-skinned girl, whose comment directed towards the darker-skinned boy, seemed to have the explicit intention playfulness, but the implicit effect of race-related prejudice. After s...
Post a Comment
Read more